This narration is from a previous version of the study and may include a combined recording of multiple chapters.
Miriam dies at the beginning of this chapter; Aaron dies at its end. Between those losses come thirst, a failure at the rock, and a road closed by Edom. God remains merciful, yet His servants are accountable for how they reveal Him. Water flows for the congregation even when Moses and Aaron fail to hallow the Lord before it. A visible result is not the whole measure of faithful service.
Numbers 19 has given purification from contact with death. Numbers 20 now brings death into the leadership of Israel and prepares for the detour and bronze serpent of Numbers 21. The account honors Moses’ and Aaron’s place in God’s work without concealing their failure. Its warning belongs especially to those whose words help another person imagine what God is like: priests, deacons, teachers, parents, and every Christian entrusted with another person’s care.
Numbers 20:1-5; Greek/Brenton 20:1-5: Grief and thirst at Kadesh
Numbering note: NKJV and Brenton use the same chapter and verse labels. Brenton calls this “the wilderness of Sin,” while NKJV calls it the Wilderness of Zin. The setting is Kadesh, here spelled Cades; it should not be confused with the Wilderness of Sin in Exodus 16:1. Mariam is Miriam.
Brenton chapter 20
1: And the children of Israel, even the whole congregation, came into the wilderness of Sin, in the first month, and the people abode in Cades; and Mariam died there, and was buried there. 2: And there was no water for the congregation: and they gathered themselves together against Moses and Aaron. 3: And the people reviled Moses, saying, Would we had died in the destruction of our brethren before the Lord! 4: And wherefore have ye brought up the congregation of the Lord into this wilderness, to kill us and our cattle? 5: And wherefore is this? Ye have brought us up out of Egypt, that we should come into this evil place; a place where there is no sowing, neither figs, nor vines, nor pomegranates, neither is there water to drink.
Light from the Word 🕯️
Miriam’s death is stated in one verse. The sister who watched over Moses as an infant and led the women in praise after the sea is buried at Kadesh. Israel’s long story of deliverance does not exempt its servants from mortality. The loss is real even when the narrative gives no extended lament.
Then comes a water crisis. The need is serious: the congregation and its cattle have nothing to drink. The sin lies not in thirst itself but in the accusation that God’s deliverance has brought them here to die. They wish they had perished with their brethren and call the wilderness an evil place. Grain, figs, vines, and pomegranates are absent; the promised land has not yet been reached.
The complaint again makes Egypt the alternative to God’s difficult road. The people cannot yet distinguish a need that can be brought before Him from an accusation that denies His faithfulness. In prayer, we may speak honestly of deprivation. We begin to lose truth when we conclude that deprivation proves God has ceased to love us.
Grief and need stand close together in this chapter. The text does not say that Miriam’s death caused Moses’ later failure, and we should not invent his inward state. It does allow us to see that holy service takes place amid losses, demands, and pressure. The person who carries responsibility still needs to bring his own sorrow to God.
Numbers 20:6-8; Greek/Brenton 20:6-8: The command at the tabernacle door
Numbering note: The labels agree. God’s command here is to speak to the rock; compare the earlier command to strike the rock in Exodus 17:6.
Brenton chapter 20
6: And Moses and Aaron went from before the assembly to the door of the tabernacle of witness, and they fell upon their faces; and the glory of the Lord appeared to them. 7: And the Lord spoke to Moses, saying, 8: Take thy rod, and call the assembly, thou and Aaron thy brother, and speak ye to the rock before them, and it shall give forth its waters; and ye shall bring forth for them water out of the rock, and give drink to the congregation and their cattle.
Light from the Word 🕯️
Moses and Aaron first respond rightly. They leave the accusing assembly, go to the tabernacle door, and fall on their faces. The glory of the Lord appears. Their prayer puts the crisis before the One whose presence makes the congregation His people.
The Lord’s command is precise: take the rod, gather the assembly, and speak to the rock before them. The promise reaches the cattle as well as the people. The Lord sees the whole need and gives a word by which it can be met.
Exodus 17 cannot supply the instructions for this moment. There Moses was commanded to strike; here he is commanded to speak. A former act of obedience must not become a method repeated without listening. The servant’s past experience is a gift, but it is not a substitute for the word he is now given.
That difference bears on ordinary responsibilities. Familiarity with a child, a class, or a ministry can make us assume that we already know what is required. Prayer interrupts that assumption. We are called to be faithful to the living Lord, not merely efficient with a successful technique.
Numbers 20:9-13; Greek/Brenton 20:9-13: Mercy flows and the servant is judged
Numbering note: The labels agree. Brenton translates the name Meribah as “the water of Strife” in verse 13 and recalls it in verse 24.
Brenton chapter 20
9: And Moses took his rod which was before the Lord, as the Lord commanded. 10: And Moses and Aaron assembled the congregation before the rock, and said to them, Hear me, ye disobedient ones; must we bring you water out of this rock? 11: And Moses lifted up his hand and struck the rock with his rod twice; and much water came forth, and the congregation drank, and their cattle. 12: And the Lord said to Moses and Aaron, Because ye have not believed me to sanctify me before the children of Israel, therefore ye shall not bring this congregation into the land which I have given them. 13: This is the water of Strife, because the children of Israel spoke insolently before the Lord, and he was sanctified in them.
Light from the Word 🕯️
Moses takes the rod as commanded. But when he addresses the assembly, he says, “Hear me, ye disobedient ones; must we bring you water out of this rock?” He then strikes the rock twice. The people and cattle drink from an abundant supply, yet the Lord says that Moses and Aaron have not believed Him so as to sanctify Him before Israel.
The divine explanation governs our reading. Failure to believe and hallow God is more than an error in technique. The sign is meant to reveal the Lord before His people; the servants act otherwise than He commanded. Psalm 106:32-33 (LXX 105:32-33) also recalls the event and says that Moses spoke rashly. That later scriptural witness supports the warning about speech without reducing the whole judgment to a speculative account of Moses’ feelings.
God’s mercy reaches the thirsty despite the failure of those charged to reveal it. This should console the person wounded by a servant’s conduct and sober the servant who takes success as proof of faithfulness. The water was real. So was the failure. A lesson understood, a task completed, or a beautiful chant cannot excuse contempt toward the person receiving it.
Gems from the Fathers 💎
St. John Chrysostom, explaining 1 Corinthians 10:4, insists that the source of Israel’s water was Christ’s gracious action rather than a natural power in the stone: “For it was not the nature of the rock which sent forth the water, (such is his meaning,) else would it as well have gushed out before this time: but another sort of Rock, a spiritual One, performed the whole, even Christ who was every where with them and wrought all the wonders.”1
This is an exposition of St. Paul’s account of the wilderness, not a direct commentary on Moses’ particular act in Numbers 20. It makes the Christian reading clear nonetheless. Israel’s drink belongs to Christ’s care for His people. The visible water directs the Church toward the Lord who accompanies, nourishes, and saves.
St. Paul also places the water beside the spiritual food and the people’s subsequent failures. Receiving a gift does not remove the need for obedience. For Christians who receive Christ’s sacramental gifts, this is a call to reverent life, not to fear that the gift itself is insufficient.
Christ the Rock and the once-for-all offering
The rock’s water can be contemplated beside Christ’s promise of living water in John 7:37-39 and the blood and water from His pierced side in John 19:34. These are Christian connections within the scriptural witness, not permission to assign every stroke a separate sacramental meaning.
The familiar reflection that Christ is not to be struck again must also remain exact. Romans 6:10 and Hebrews 10:10 confess the once-for-all character of His death and offering. Moses’ repeated blows are not themselves a doctrine of a repeated Passion. They can, in reflection, warn us against making contempt or manipulation the means of offering Christ’s gifts. The Church proclaims His victory and participates in His one offering; she does not compel the Savior to suffer anew.
The Church’s Voice in Worship ⛪
Numbers 20:1-13 is the second prophecy at the Ninth Hour on Wednesday of Holy Pascha. It follows Genesis 24:1-9 and precedes Proverbs 1:11-35. The Gospel is Matthew 26:3-16, which recounts the council’s plot, the anointing at Bethany, and Judas’ agreement to betray the Lord.2
The placement’s spiritual meaning is offered here as reflection. The Church approaches the willing Passion of the true Rock, from whom life flows even in the face of rejection. At the same time, Moses’ failure asks the hearer to stand near the mysteries with a truthful heart. Neither a sacred role nor proximity to holy events makes unbelief harmless. Christ’s obedience reveals the Father without the distortion that marks His servants’ failures.
Numbers 20:14-21; Greek/Brenton 20:14-21: A brother closes the road
Numbering note: NKJV and Brenton labels agree. Cades is Kadesh, and the appeal to Edom as brother recalls the kinship of Jacob and Esau.
Brenton chapter 20
14: And Moses sent messengers from Cades to the king of Edom, saying, Thus says thy brother Israel; Thou knowest all the distress that has come upon us. 15: And how our fathers went down into Egypt, and we sojourned in Egypt many days, and the Egyptians afflicted us and our fathers. 16: And we cried to the Lord, and the Lord heard our voice, and sent an angel and brought us out of Egypt; and now we are in the city of Cades, at the extremity of thy coasts. 17: We will pass through thy land: we will not go through the fields, nor through the vineyards, nor will we drink water out of thy cistern: we will go by the king’s highway; we will not turn aside to the right hand or to the left, until we have passed thy borders. 18: And Edom said to him, Thou shalt not pass through me, and if otherwise, I will go forth to meet thee in war. 19: And the children of Israel say to him, We will pass by the mountain; and if I and my cattle drink of thy water, I will pay thee: but it is no matter of importance, we will go by the mountain. 20: And he said, Thou shalt not pass through me; and Edom went forth to meet him with a great host, and a mighty hand. 21: So Edom refused to allow Israel to pass through his borders, and Israel turned away from him.
Light from the Word 🕯️
Moses begins with kinship: “Thus says thy brother Israel.” He recounts affliction in Egypt, the cry to the Lord, and deliverance. Genesis 25 and 33 give the earlier story of Jacob and Esau behind this address. The request asks Edom to show mercy to a brother in distress.
Israel offers a peaceful passage on the king’s highway. The messengers promise to leave fields and vineyards alone and later offer payment for water. These are concrete limits, not an invitation to let an entire camp take whatever it wants. Edom nevertheless refuses, threatens war, and brings out a great host.
Israel turns away. The narrative gives no conquest of Edom here. Later, Deuteronomy 23:7 will forbid abhorring the Edomite because he is a brother, while Obadiah 10-12 will judge violence against Jacob. Brotherhood makes mercy an obligation even when conflict has made it difficult.
For the Christian reader, the restraint in this scene is worth receiving. A just request does not always open a road, and refusal does not always authorize force. The people who have received water must still accept a detour. God’s faithfulness is not confined to the path we hoped He would open.
Numbers 20:22-29; Greek/Brenton 20:22-29: The garments pass to another
Numbering note: NKJV and Brenton labels agree. Mount Or is Mount Hor. Aaron’s death is dated later in Numbers 33:38-39 to the first day of the fifth month of the fortieth year; that date is not supplied at the opening of Numbers 20.
Brenton chapter 20
22: And they departed from Cades; and the children of Israel, even the whole congregation, came to Mount Or. 23: And the Lord spoke to Moses and Aaron in mount Or, on the borders of the land of Edom, saying, 24: Let Aaron be added to his people; for ye shall certainly not go into the land which I have given the children of Israel, because ye provoked me at the water of strife. 25: Take Aaron, and Eleazar his son, and bring them up to the mount Or before all the congregation; 26: and take Aaron’s apparel from off him, and put it on Eleazar his son: and let Aaron die there and be added to his people. 27: And Moses did as the Lord commanded him, and took him up to mount Or, before all the congregation. 28: And he took Aaron’s garments off him, and put them on Eleazar his son, and Aaron died on the top of the mountain; and Moses and Eleazar came down from the mountain. 29: And all the congregation saw that Aaron was dead: and they wept for Aaron thirty days, even all the house of Israel.
Light from the Word 🕯️
At Mount Hor the Lord recalls the failure at the water of Strife. Aaron will be gathered to his people without entering the land. Moses takes him and Eleazar up the mountain, removes Aaron’s garments, and puts them on his son. Aaron dies, and Moses and Eleazar return to the congregation.
The transfer is public. The priesthood continues, but Aaron’s own life ends. His garments belong to the calling and are entrusted to another. Service is something a person receives, carries, and eventually surrenders. Its continuity rests on God, not on the permanence of one servant.
Israel mourns Aaron for thirty days. The judgment does not require them to erase his life or withhold grief. The man who made the golden calf also stood between the dead and the living. Scripture can hold sin, mercy, faithful service, and consequence within the account of one person. We should neither sanctify every act of a beloved servant nor let one failure obliterate the good God worked through him.
Hebrews 7:23-24 explains the succession of the old priests through their mortality, then proclaims Christ’s priesthood as enduring because He continues forever. The garments that pass from Aaron to Eleazar prepare the reader to appreciate that difference. The Church’s hope is not an endless line of persons who never fail or die. It is the living Christ, whose priesthood sustains every faithful ministry.
The name Moses gave Joshua in Numbers 13:16 looks ahead to the succession commanded in Numbers 27:18-23. As Christian reflection, the servant who leads Israel onward prepares us to hear Hebrews 4:8-11: the lasting rest is God’s gift, brought to its fullness in Christ.
Moses too will not lead Israel into Canaan. Yet Matthew 17:3 and Luke 9:30-31 show him with Christ at the Transfiguration, speaking of the Lord’s saving departure. As reflection, that scene keeps the loss of entry into Canaan from being mistaken for the end of his communion with God. Temporal consequence and God’s final mercy cannot be collapsed into a single verdict.
Spiritual Fruit 🍇
Bring need to God before turning it into accusation. The congregation truly lacks water. In prayer, name the deprivation plainly, and resist the further claim that God has brought you here only to destroy you. Honest lament can remain within trust even when relief is delayed.
Listen before repeating a familiar method. Moses’ former obedience cannot replace the present command. Before correcting a child, teaching a class, or responding to a demanding person, pause long enough to ask what fidelity requires now. Habit can save effort while concealing impatience.
Examine the spirit as well as the result. If the task succeeded but another person was belittled, do not use the success to justify the wound. Apologize for the words or conduct that were wrong. A servant of Christ must care how God’s mercy is made visible.
Accept a detour without relinquishing the promise. Israel turns away from Edom. A refused opportunity need not become a war with everyone who blocked it. Take the next obedient step, seek sound counsel where needed, and let God lead beyond the road you expected.
Prepare to surrender an assignment. Aaron’s garments pass to Eleazar. Help another person learn the work, share what is needed for its continuation, and pray for the person who will succeed you. The ability to let service continue without you is itself a form of faithful service.
Lord Jesus Christ, Rock of our salvation, give living water to the thirsty and gentleness to those entrusted with Your gifts. Receive the grief we carry and restrain the harshness we are tempted to pass on. Teach us to listen, to serve truthfully, and to entrust the work to You when our part is finished.
Teaching Notes
Numbers 20:1-5
- Discuss: What distinguishes the people’s real need from their accusation against deliverance?
- Emphasize: Grief belongs to the chapter, but its psychological effect on Moses is not stated.
- Watch for: Saying that every complaint about deprivation is sinful.
Numbers 20:6-8
- Discuss: Why is Exodus 17’s instruction insufficient for this moment?
- Connect: Prayer puts the servant back under the Lord’s present word.
Numbers 20:9-13
- Discuss: How can water flow while the servants are judged?
- Emphasize: Use God’s explanation in verse 12 and the later witness of Psalm 106:32-33 (LXX 105:32-33).
- Connect: Christ the Rock; the Wednesday Ninth Hour prophecy and its Gospel.
- Watch for: Claiming that the Church repeats Christ’s Passion or reducing His willing sacrifice to helpless suffering.
Numbers 20:14-21
- Discuss: What concrete assurances accompany Israel’s request, and what does its turning away show?
- Connect: Genesis 25 and 33; Deuteronomy 23:7; Obadiah 10-12.
Numbers 20:22-29
- Discuss: Why do the garments pass publicly while the congregation is still permitted to mourn?
- Emphasize: Mortality requires succession; Christ’s priesthood continues forever.
- Watch for: Assigning the later death date of Aaron to every event in this chapter.
Sources
Embedded Scripture is from Brenton’s English Septuagint (LXX). “Sanctify” or “hallow” God here means to reveal and honor His holiness before the people. Brenton’s “water of Strife” is Meribah; Or is Hor, Cades is Kadesh, and Mariam is Miriam. The Sin/Zin contrast identifies the Kadesh setting without proposing a manuscript history for the spelling.
Exodus 17:1-7; Numbers 19; 21; 33:38-39; Psalm 106:32-33 (LXX 105:32-33); 1 Corinthians 10:1-5; John 7:37-39; 19:34; Hebrews 7:23-25; 10:10; Matthew 17:3; Luke 9:30-31.
St. John Chrysostom, Homilies on First Corinthians, Homily 23, section 3, explaining 1 Corinthians 10:1-5.
Coptic Holy Pascha, Wednesday, Ninth Hour, prophecy and Gospel readings.
Footnotes
-
St. John Chrysostom, Homilies on First Corinthians 23.3, on 1 Corinthians 10:4, NPNF1 12, 🔗. ↩
-
Coptic Holy Pascha, Wednesday, Ninth Hour, second prophecy, Numbers 20:1-13; first prophecy, Genesis 24:1-9; third prophecy, Proverbs 1:11-35; Gospel, Matthew 26:3-16. Coptic Reader, Special, Pascha, Wednesday, Ninth Hour, 🔗. ↩