Illuminated Coptic sanctuary banner

Sirach 20 - The Time to Speak and the Time to Be Silent

10 min read

A true sentence can still be badly spoken. Sirach 20 begins with an unseemly rebuke and ends with wisdom that must not be buried. Between those points, the chapter refuses an easy rule that silence is always holy or speaking always brave. Love must learn when the word is needed, what intention carries it, and what cost we are willing to bear for its truth.

Rebuke Without Violence, Silence Without Resentment (Sirach 20:1-8)

1 There is a reproof that is not comely: again, some man holdeth his tongue, and he is wise. 2 It is much better to reprove, than to be angry secretly: 3 and he that confesseth his fault shall be preserved from hurt. 4 As is the lust of an eunuch to deflower a virgin; so is he that executeth judgment with violence. 5 There is one that keepeth silence, and is found wise: and another by much babbling becometh hateful. 6 Some man holdeth his tongue, because he hath not to answer: and some keepeth silence, knowing his time. 7 A wise man will hold his tongue till he see opportunity: but a babbler and a fool will regard no time. 8 He that useth many words shall be abhorred; and he that taketh to himself authority therein shall be hated.

The first contrasts distinguish actions that look alike. Reproof can be fitting or disfigured; silence can arise from wisdom or from having nothing to say. Hidden anger is no substitute for an honest, measured rebuke, and confession can preserve a person from further hurt. Wisdom seeks the right response, not the posture that makes the speaker appear least troublesome.

Verse 4 uses a disturbing sexual image involving a eunuch and a virgin to condemn judgment carried out with violence. The comparison presents a frustrated or contradictory desire, not a model for conduct. The force of the warning is that violent coercion defeats justice’s purpose. It licenses neither sexual violence nor contempt for a person with a bodily difference. Christian authority must seek truth and protection without making another person’s humiliation its instrument.

The wise speaker waits for an opportunity because a hearer is a person, not a surface upon which an argument is written. But waiting can also become a disguise for resentment. If a fault needs to be addressed, rehearsing it inwardly while refusing a responsible conversation will not heal it. Prayer can make a pause fruitful: ask for a word that is truthful enough to help and gentle enough to be received, while using appropriate safeguards when direct conversation would be unsafe.

Gifts That Leave a Debt of Humiliation (Sirach 20:9-17)

9 There is a sinner that hath good success in evil things; and there is a gain that turneth to loss. 10 There is a gift that shall not profit thee; and there is a gift whose recompence is double. 11 There is an abasement because of glory; and there is that lifteth up his head from a low estate. 12 There is that buyeth much for a little, and repayeth it sevenfold. 13 A wise man by his words maketh himself beloved: but the graces of fools shall be poured out. 14 The gift of a fool shall do thee no good when thou hast it; neither yet of the envious for his necessity: for he looketh to receive many things for one. 15 He giveth little, and upbraideth much; he openeth his mouth like a crier; to-day he lendeth, and to-morrow will he ask it again: such an one is to be hated of God and man. 16 The fool saith, I have no friends, I have no thank for all my good deeds, and they that eat my bread speak evil of me. 17 How oft, and of how many shall he be laughed to scorn!

Apparent gain can become loss, and an apparent lowering can prepare an unexpected rising. These reversals train us to judge by more than the immediate result. A gift may bring real help or become an expensive entanglement. Ben Sira’s fool gives little, announces it loudly, demands disproportionate return, and then complains that no one appreciates him. The generosity is performing a transaction it will not honestly name.

The details make the spiritual diagnosis plain. A loan is called back before it can serve its purpose; reproach grows larger than the gift; the recipient is expected to provide gratitude and loyalty on demand. This can occur with money, favors, caregiving, or ministry. The giver turns another person’s need into a claim upon the person’s freedom. Even good labor can become bitter when it is used to purchase recognition.

Christ’s teaching about giving without display and loving without calculating a return brings the remedy close to the heart (Matthew 6:1-4; Luke 6:34-35). We can state a loan’s terms honestly and acknowledge our limits. What requires repentance is the hidden bill sent afterward for admiration, agreement, or control. A gift becomes freer when its giver can let the recipient remain a person rather than a debtor of affection.

The Shame That Produces False Promises (Sirach 20:18-26)

18 To slip upon a pavement is better than to slip with the tongue: so the fall of the wicked shall come speedily. 19 An unseasonable tale will always be in the mouth of the unwise. 20 A wise sentence shall be rejected when it cometh out of a fool’s mouth; for he will not speak it in due season. 21 There is that is hindered from sinning through want: and when he taketh rest, he shall not be troubled. 22 There is that destroyeth his own soul through bashfulness, and by accepting of persons overthroweth himself. 23 There is that for bashfulness promiseth to his friend, and maketh him his enemy for nothing. 24 A lie is a foul blot in a man, yet it is continually in the mouth of the untaught. 25 A thief is better than a man that is accustomed to lie: but they both shall have destruction to heritage. 26 The disposition of a liar is dishonourable, and his shame is ever with him.

A slipped foot may heal sooner than a slipped tongue. The chapter then joins untimely stories, misplaced wisdom, bashful promises, and habitual lying. Timing matters because a true observation can be made useless by the occasion in which it is offered. The warning is not that truth must flatter. It is that truth should be spoken with attention to the hearer’s need and the speaker’s real duty.

Verses 22-23 expose the fear of disappointing someone. A person agrees out of embarrassment, makes a promise he cannot keep, and creates the hostility he hoped to avoid. Many relationships are harmed by this reluctant yes. A timely, courteous limit is often kinder than an agreeable fiction. Christ’s command about simple truthfulness helps us bear the discomfort of a genuine answer.

The comparison between liar and thief does not commend theft. Both face ruin, and habitual lying is singled out because it corrodes the trust on which ordinary life depends. A promise, apology, or report becomes difficult to receive when truth is treated as adjustable. Repentance begins with particular repairs: correct the false statement, acknowledge the unkept promise, and accept that trust may recover slowly.

Let Wisdom Serve Rather Than Hide (Sirach 20:27-31)

27 A wise man shall promote himself to honour with his words: and he that hath understanding will please great men. 28 He that tilleth his land shall increase his heap: and he that pleaseth great men shall get pardon for iniquity. 29 Presents and gifts blind the eyes of the wise, and stop up his mouth that he cannot reprove. 30 Wisdom that is hid, and treasure that is hoarded up, what profit is in them both? 31 Better is he that hideth his folly than a man that hideth his wisdom.

Wise speech can bring honor, while skill in dealing with powerful people can obtain favor. Verse 28 reports the dangerous fact that pleasing the great can even win pardon for wrongdoing. It should not be promoted into a Christian strategy of purchasing impunity. The next verse exposes the cost: gifts blind judgment and close a mouth that ought to reprove. Influence can succeed outwardly while corrupting its possessor inwardly.

The ending draws a necessary boundary around silence. Hidden wisdom is like hoarded treasure that never helps anyone. Concealing foolishness is better than broadcasting it, but burying understanding deprives a neighbor of a gift meant for service. Matthew 5:15 supplies a fitting parallel of a lamp giving light, and Matthew 25:25 portrays the fear that buries an entrusted gift. These are resonances, not demonstrated quotations from Sirach.

The chapter has traveled from untimely rebuke to necessary witness. A Christian learns to be quiet when vanity, anger, or gossip wants a voice, and to speak when truth or care requires it. Christ’s grace can free both the compulsive talker and the fearful servant. In each case the aim is the same: words available for love rather than captive to the speaker’s need for safety or importance.

Spiritual Fruit 🍇

Turn one hidden resentment into responsible speech. Identify a grievance you keep rehearsing. If a conversation is safe and belongs to your duty, pray, choose an appropriate time, and describe the actual matter without a catalogue of motives. If direct contact would be unsafe, seek counsel and proper protection instead. The goal is a truthful response, not the satisfaction of delivering every sentence anger has prepared. Afterward, examine whether you listened as well as spoke, and leave the unfinished part of the matter with God instead of continuing the argument inwardly.

Give without sending a hidden bill. Recall one kindness for which you still expect a particular response. Name that expectation honestly before God. Where terms were never stated, release the claim to repayment in admiration or agreement. If future help needs limits, state them in advance. A modest gift freely given can serve another person better than extravagant help surrounded by reproach.

Practice a truthful limit. Before agreeing to a request, consider your real duties, resources, and ability. Give one courteous answer that you can actually keep. If you have already promised what you cannot perform, correct it promptly and apologize without blaming the requester. The short pain of honesty can prevent the longer injury of disappointment. Truthfulness becomes a form of care for the person who would otherwise plan around an unreal promise.

Offer the wisdom you have been hiding. Choose one useful insight, skill, or warning that fear has kept unavailable. Share it in the right setting without presenting yourself as indispensable. This may mean helping a new servant, explaining a task patiently, or raising a concern through proper channels. Ask Christ to govern both the silence and the word. The mouth can become quiet enough to listen and courageous enough to serve, while the gift entrusted to you finally gives light beyond yourself.

Reading statusLoading your browser-local progress
Saved only in this browser

Created: | Updated:

Page Connections

Backlinks